?

Log in

No account? Create an account
The Umbrella Organisation

The Umbrella Organisation

May the power of the brolly live on!

Previous Entry Share Next Entry
Mark Gatiss and Steven Moffat Booksigning, Waterstone's Piccadilly
Raks New Profile Pic Square
rakspatel wrote in mycroft_brolly


Thank you to an anonymous livejournaller for tipping me off about this! Mark Gatiss and Steven Moffat will be doing a booksigning of the Sherlock Holmes stories, where they have written the introductions, at Waterstone's Piccadilly on Wednesday 2 November at 5.30pm.

Follow the link for more details:
http://www.waterstones.com/waterstonesweb/displayDetailEvent.do?searchType=2&store=279|WATERSTONE%27S%20PICCADILLY&sFilter=1

It says that Mark and Steven will be signing copies of these two books but that no merchandise or memorabilia will be signed. This is a good event to go to if you want to meet Mark and Steven, but not if you want to get an autograph on something of value, either in monetary terms or to you personally.

I have Mark's book. If I am honest, I am disappointed in the quality. There are much much much nicer editions available at better prices. The Mark and Steven intros are only 2-3 pages long. The editions have no illustrations, Paget or otherwise. The editions have no photos. There is no "Sherlock" in them, bar the cover branding, which I think is poor (and if I am brutally honest, completely naff!). It is clearly targeting the Dr Who/youth market which misses the point of the new audience/readers attracted to the Canon through Sherlock. So great opportunity to meet Mark and Steven but I do not recommend these editions of the stories in the slightest!

Follow the link for an edition I do thoroughly recommend:
http://mycroft-brolly.livejournal.com/164009.html


  • 1
These editions are rather a con. New covers on old content bar the introduction. But if they get a new generation reading original Conan Doyle I suppose that they serve their purpose. I guess that is what Mark Gatiss and Steven Moffat intend, and why they endorse the product. :-)

The editions are a huge con - they are cheap and tacky. The intros take 2-3 mins to read - I would just read the intros in Waterstone's and not buy the books.

The BBC, and Mark and Steven, can do a lot better than this. The Dr Who merchandising is very good.

I think the books would have been a lot better with some illustrations or photos and a better quality - less tacky - cover. Or if it was a "fine" edition, which looked and felt gorgeous, and that could be given as a gift. Or they should have had more of a "Sherlock" tie-in/theme. I could go on and on!

The long and the short of it is, I would not give this edition as a present to anyone - child or adult.


  • 1